The Torture A Critique Of The Ticking Bomb Argument

applied by the Nazis. I completely disagree because there is no way to compare the atrocities of the Nazis to few cases of enhanced interrogation by the United States. My interpretation of Hunsingher’s conclusion is that it goes to high extremes because the methods used by the Nazis were far more inhumane. According to Jessica Wolfendale, the author of the article â€Å"Training Torture: A Critique of the Ticking Bomb Argument,† â€Å"We have every reason to doubt that military and political authorities will use torture only in extreme cases† (Wolfendale 270). In other words, she states that if torture becomes acceptable, the government will find different ways to apply it to everyone with no exceptions or restrictions to achieve a goal. My interpretation of Wolfendale’s statements is that an individual has the right to question and demand answers. She is right to assume that torture is not going to stop in extreme cases. I agree with her view that it will get out of hand, because the government seem to look for new ways to apply laws. In communities where the use of torture is a controversial, most people would agree that it is wrong and it should not be applied. According to an article â€Å"Torture in the Public Mind,† written by Mivaslov, Ninic and Jennifer, Ramos, they state: â€Å"70 percent of who participated in a study said that torture is wrong† (Ninic and Ramos 242). To put this in other words Ninic and Ramos state that people have negative views of torture, and thinkShow MoreRelatedThe use of torture has become a prominent matter of dispute as we enter an age of the global war on1600 Words   |  7 PagesThe use of torture has become a prominent matter of dispute as we enter an age of the global war on terror. The debate on whether it has become morally permissible to torture terrorists is argued by many as the legitimacy of such actions are brought into question in a world where global terror is outstanding. With the use of the ticking time bomb scenario, some make a desirable case tha t in special circumstances, there is a right to torture individuals implicated is acts of mass violence. Yet manyRead MoreThe Legal And Ethical Perspective Of The World War II1354 Words   |  6 Pageshuman history, enemy combatants of the defeated forces were generally taken as war prisoners, often expected to confront brutal tortures or agonizing executions. Such trend managed to steer its way into recent human history. Some of the most atrocious crimes committed against mankind were witnessed during the second World War where prisoners of war underwent unthinkable torture procedures either to give confessions or for the purpose of human experimentation. Hence, participants of the Geneva ConventionRead MoreShould the United States Use Torture to Gather Information1474 Words   |  6 Pageswith the question of, whether their government intelligence agencies should be prohibited from using torture to gather information. According to Michael Ignatieff, this is the hardest case of w hat he describes as ‘lesser evil ethics’—a political ethics predicated on the idea that in emergencies leaders must choose between different evils Before the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, torture was viewed by most American’s as only actions that brutal dictators would employ on their citizens, toRead MoreHuman Torture Essay1559 Words   |  6 PagesI. Introduction The American citizens have been wrestling with the question of whether their government intelligence agencies should be prohibited from using torture to gather information. Since the terrorist attacks on September 11th the American government vowed to do whatever it took to hunt down those involved. In May 2004, The New Yorker released photographs from the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq. The disturbing pictures were released on the internet showing bodies of naked Iraqis piled onto each